Does deductive validity alone guarantee that all premises are true?
- Only for long arguments
- No
- Yes, by definition
- Only for moral arguments
Answer and explanation
No
Validity concerns the logical relationship, not premise truth.
Subjects
Choose questions individually, practise online, or create a worksheet with matching answers. Counts include generated variants, not only authored originals.
No
Validity concerns the logical relationship, not premise truth.
Validity plus true premises
Both form and premise truth matter.
Benefits, harms, rights and burdens may be distributed differently. Ignoring affected people can hide important considerations.
Credit distribution and stakeholder relevance.
The conclusion needs an additional premise
Challenge claims and inferences rather than attacking personal worth.
Protecting privacy while enabling useful research can create a tradeoff; a reasoned response explains safeguards, benefits and remaining risks.
Accept other justified goal conflicts.
3
4−1=3 distinct statements in the stipulated case.
A deductively valid argument has a form in which true premises guarantee the conclusion. Validity does not itself prove the premises true.
Grades 9–12A deductively valid argument has a form in which true premises guarantee the conclusion. Validity does not itself prove the premises true.
Grades 9–12